A photograph of damage to St John's Church, Lyttelton.
Damage to a footpath on Bracken Street in Avonside.
Damage to a footpath on Bracken Street in Avonside.
A photograph of the damaged Canterbury Provincial Council Buildings.
A photograph of a damaged retaining wall in Lyttelton.
Damaged buildings on Manchester Street, behind the cordon fence.
A photograph of a damaged building on Manchester Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Manchester Street.
A photograph of damaged gas bottles on Manchester Street.
A photograph showing the damaged Octagon Live restaurant building.
A photograph of a damaged building on London Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
A photograph of the damaged Durham Street Methodist Church.
A photograph of the damaged Durham Street Methodist Church.
A photograph of the damaged Durham Street Methodist Church.
A photograph of the damaged Durham Street Methodist Church.
A photograph of damage to St John's Church, Lyttelton.
A photograph of a damaged retaining wall in Lyttelton.
A photograph of damaged buildings on London Street, Lyttelton.
A photograph of a damaged building on Tuam Street.
Utility managers are always looking for appropriate tools to estimate seismic damage in wastewater networks located in earthquake prone areas. Fragility curves, as an appropriate tool, are recommended for seismic vulnerability analysis of buried pipelines, including pressurised and unpressurised networks. Fragility curves are developed in pressurised networks mainly for water networks. Fragility curves are also recommended for seismic analysis in unpressurised networks. Applying fragility curves in unpressurised networks affects accuracy of seismic damage estimation. This study shows limitations of these curves in unpressurised networks. Multiple case study analysis was applied to demonstrate the limitations of the application of fragility curves in unpressurised networks in New Zealand. Four wastewater networks within New Zealand were selected as case studies and various fragility curves used for seismic damage estimation. Observed damage in unpressurised networks after the 2007 earthquake in Gisborne and the 2010 earthquake in Christchurch demonstrate the appropriateness of the applied fragility curves to New Zealand wastewater networks. This study shows that the application of fragility curves, which are developed from pressurised networks, cannot be accurately used for seismic damage assessment in unpressurised wastewater networks. This study demonstrated the effects of different parameters on seismic damage vulnerability of unpressurised networks.
A photograph captioned by BeckerFraserPhotos, "The damaged Crichton Cobbers Youth and Community Club. The photograph was taken from further along Fitzgerald Avenue where the damaged corner is not visible".
None
None