Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9945
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9939
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9933
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9932
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9949
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9921
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9924
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9923
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9952
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9942
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9950
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9938
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9940
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9929
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9927
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9935
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9956
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9941
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9948
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9944
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9934
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9922
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9953
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9955
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9931
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9928
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9954
Post February 22 Earthquake Damage Corner Opawa Road and Aynsley Terrace, Opawa PWS-2011-03-09-DSC9947
Eccentrically Braced Frames (EBFs) are a widely used seismic resisting structural steel system. Since their inception in the late 1970s, they have been a viable option with an available stiffness that is between simple braced systems and moment resisting systems. A similar concept, the linked column frame (LCF), uses shear links between two closely spaced columns. In both cases, the key component is the active link or the shear link, and this component is the objective of this study. The performance of high rise EBF buildings in the 2010 and 2011 Christchurch earthquakes was beyond that which was expected, especially considering the very high accelerations recorded. As the concrete high-rises were torn down, two EBF buildings remained standing and only required some structural repair. These events prompted a renewed interest in bolted shear links, as well as their performance. While some research into replaceable shear links had already been done (Mansour, 2011), the objectives of this study were to improve on the shear link itself, with the consideration that links built in the future are likely to be bolted. The main components of this study were to: 1. Reduce or eliminate the requirements for intermediate web stiffeners, as they were suspected of being detrimental to performance. Furthermore, any reduction in stiffening requirements is a direct fabrication cost saving. Links with low web aspect ratios were found to achieve exceptional ductilities when no stiffeners were included, prompting new design equations. 2. Ensure that the stresses in the ends of links are adequately transferred into the endplates without causing fractures. Although most of the experimental links had web doubler plates included, four had varied lengths of such doubler plates from 0.0 in. to 8.0 in. The link without any doubler plates performed to a similar level to its peers, and thus it is likely that links with quality end details may not need web doubler plates at all. 3. Evaluate the performance of a link with double sided stiffeners without the use of web welds, as opposed to conventional single sided, welded stiffeners. This link performed well, and web-weld-less double sided stiffeners may be an economical alternative to conventional stiffeners for deeper sections of links. 4. Evaluate the performance of a link with thin endplates that are made efficient with the use of gusset plates. This link performed to an acceptable level and provides evidence for a cost effective alternative to thick endplates, especially considering the high overstrength end moments in links, typically requiring 16-bolt connections. 5. Examine the potential use of an alternative EBF arrangement where the collector beam is over sized, and the link section is formed by cutting out parts of the beam's web. After running a series of finite element models each with a unique variation, a number of approximate design rules were derived such that future research could develop this idea further experimentally. 6. Ensure that during testing, the secondary elements (members that are not the shear link), do not yield and are not close to yielding. None of the instrumented elements experienced any unexpected yielding, however the concerns for high stresses in the collector beam panel zone during design were warranted. The use of an existing New Zealand design equation is recommended as an extra check for design codes worldwide. The above objectives were mainly conducted experimentally, except: the data set for item 1 was greatly expanded through the use of a calibrated numerical model which was then used in an extensive parametric study; item 5 was purely finite element based; and, a small parametric study was included for item 3 in an attempt to expand on the trends found there.
The influence of nonlinear soil-foundation-structure interaction (SFSI) on the performance of multi-storey buildings during earthquake events has become increasingly important in earthquake resistant design. For buildings on shallow foundations, SFSI refers to nonlinear geometric effects associated with uplift of the foundation from the supporting soil as well as nonlinear soil deformation effects. These effects can potentially be beneficial for structural performance, reducing forces transmitted from ground shaking to the structure. However, there is also the potential consequence of residual settlement and rotation of the foundation. This Thesis investigates the influence of SFSI in the performance of multi-storey buildings on shallow foundations through earthquake observations, experimental testing, and development of spring-bed numerical models that can be incorporated into integrated earthquake resistant design procedures. Observations were made following the 22 February 2011 Christchurch Earthquake in New Zealand of a number of multi-storey buildings on shallow foundations that performed satisfactorily. This was predominantly the case in areas where shallow foundations, typically large raft foundations, were founded on competent gravel and where there was no significant manifestation of liquefaction at the ground surface. The properties of these buildings and the soils they are founded on directed experimental work that was conducted to investigate the mechanisms by which SFSI may have influenced the behaviour of these types of structure-foundation systems. Centrifuge experiments were undertaken at the University of Dundee, Scotland using a range of structure-foundation models and a layer of dense cohesionless soil to simulate the situation in Christchurch where multi-storey buildings on shallow foundations performed well. Three equivalent single degree of freedom (SDOF) models representing 3, 5, and 7 storey buildings with identical large raft foundations were subjected to a range of dynamic Ricker wavelet excitations and Christchurch Earthquake records to investigate the influence of SFSI on the response of the equivalent buildings. The experimental results show that nonlinear SFSI has a significant influence on structural response and overall foundation deformations, even though the large raft foundations on competent soil meant that there was a significant reserve of bearing capacity available and nonlinear deformations may have been considered to have had minimal effect. Uplift of the foundation from the supporting soil was observed across a wide range of input motion amplitudes and was particularly significant as the amplitude of motion increased. Permanent soil deformation represented by foundation settlement and residual rotation was also observed but mainly for the larger input motions. However, the absolute extent of uplift and permanent soil deformation was very small compared to the size of the foundation meaning the serviceability of the building would still likely be maintained during large earthquake events. Even so, the small extent of SFSI resulted in attenuation of the response of the structure as the equivalent period of vibration was lengthened and the equivalent damping in the system increased. The experimental work undertaken was used to validate and enhance numerical modelling techniques that are simple yet sophisticated and promote interaction between geotechnical and structural specialists involved in the design of multi-storey buildings. Spring-bed modelling techniques were utilised as they provide a balance between ease of use, and thus ease of interaction with structural specialists who have these techniques readily available in practice, and theoretically rigorous solutions. Fixed base and elastic spring-bed models showed they were unable to capture the behaviour of the structure-foundation models tested in the centrifuge experiments. SFSI spring-bed models were able to more accurately capture the behaviour but recommendations were proposed for the parameters used to define the springs so that the numerical models closely matched experimental results. From the spring-bed modelling and results of centrifuge experiments, an equivalent linear design procedure was proposed along with a procedure and recommendations for the implementation of nonlinear SFSI spring-bed models in practice. The combination of earthquake observations, experimental testing, and simplified numerical analysis has shown how SFSI is influential in the earthquake performance of multi-storey buildings on shallow foundations and should be incorporated into earthquake resistant design of these structures.